What Has Been The Most Significant Development in Goaltending in the Past Decade?

Sabres Goalie Ryan Miller.6'2" (corrected) 174 pounds. The NHL leader in GAA has been the top netminder in the league this year. Photo Courtesy of Mike Lynaugh, All Rights Reserved.
“What has been the most significant development in goaltending in the past decade?”
Rather than compile a best goalie of the decade (too obvious), or best performances of the decade (too subjective), I wanted to look a bit deeper into goaltending between the 1999-2000 season and today and ask – what has been the most significant development? To add some expertise and interest I reached out to a number of professionals for their opinion on this quesiton. From sportswriters, to coaches, a professional goalie and an Olympic gold medallist we have a number of interesting people in today’s article who responded to what I called it the one question interview.
The answers that our experts have provided are vaired, but all centre around the continued refinement of the position. Patrick Roy and Francois Allaire began the now almost universal move to the butterly in the late 80’s and early 90’s but the first half of the 2000’s has seen the position become highly technical, with refined movements by increasingly large athletes. They are all aided by professional year-round coaching and access to technology. If the 90’s made the butterfly ubiquitous amongst goaltenders, this past decade has been about perfecting it.
Thank you to all the experts who offered an answer to our question – enjoy their responses. When you’re done, please add your two cents in the comments – do you agree? disagree? What will the next ten years bring us?
Naturally, I couldn’t resist adding my own thoughts at the end – I looked at some numbers and found one thing none of our experts mentioned – and for me is was a complete surprise.
Sudashan “Sudsie” Maharaj – New York Islanders Goaltending Consultant
To me the most significant development in goaltending in the past ten years is the focus on skating/movement. Goaltenders now are so nimble on their skates and able to position themselves with such great effectiveness that they are able to execute their various save techniques with greater consistency. The trend towards an almost minimalist approach to movement within the crease and during save execution has made for a very economical and simpler style of net minding.
Sami Jo Small – Three Time Olympian
The most significant development in female goaltending has been the increase in the amount of girls playing the game. When the first world championship was hosted in Canada in 1990 there were only 8000 registered females playing hockey, now there are nearly 90,000. That has huge impact on the game and the skill development not only of the players, but of the goaltenders as well. So many more girls are playing now which means more goaltenders and hence creates better competition, better coaching and more opportunities for girls to pursue their dreams.
www.samijosmall.ca www.cwhl.ca
Twitter: @SamiJoSmall
Damien Cox – Reporter, The Toronto Star and TSN (and proud goalie-dad)
Having a son who is a goalie, I know a little about this. My guess would be – and its always equipment related – that the development of pads specifically for the the butterfly style has made it easier for modern-day practioners than it ever was for Patrick Roy. The way the pads are built now provides a padded “landing area” for the knees when a goalie goes down, and the pads are built so as to naturally rotate to form a vertical “wall” effect. It sounds like a little thing, but it has helped goalies close the five-hole even with the abolition of knee boards, and stopped the pads from being angled on the ice, thereby giving the shooter less to shoot at.
In short, before, goalies had to work with equipment designed for one style of goaltending to make it work for the butterfly. Now, even the youngest kids can use butterfly-ready gear.
TheStar.ca or Damien’s Blog The Spin on Sports
Twitter: @DamoSpin
Mike McKenna – NHL / AHL Goaltender (Lowell Devils)
The biggest change has been the influx of quality, goaltending-specific coaching at nearly every level played. Growing up, goaltending camps existed, but most occurred during the summer and were only a week or two long. Today, kids are getting quality coaching through private instruction from the time they first strap on the pads. In addition, nearly every high-level hockey club has a dedicated goalie coach nowadays. From Junior A to the NHL, teams have finally figured out that goalies need just as much -if not more- detailed instruction in order to find success.
All of this has occurred in the past 5-10 years. During juniors, college, and my first two years pro in the ECHL, I never had a goalie coach to work with during the season. My development was directly related to my own study of the position and the occasional week with Mitch Korn or Chris Economou during the summer. This forced me to develop my own drills and philosophies.
Today’s youth are lucky. They have a world of resources at their disposal as the field of coaching continues to expand. More and more ex-goalies are opening up schools and the benefits are obvious. The only downfall is that we are all starting to play extremely similar and the individuality of the game is rapidly disappearing. 10 years from now you won’t see anyone playing like Marty Brodeur or Tim Thomas. The development of the butterfly and associated movements has proven too effective for goaltenders (and their coaches) to ignore it.
Twitter: @MikeMcKenna56
Check out Mike’s coach Chris Economou on YouTube
Steve McKichan – Future Pro Goalie School, Former NHL Goaltender and Coach
In the last decade, we have seen goalies excel to levels never seen in the game’s history. In fact the goalies have been so good the NHL has been forced to attempt to mitigate their success by shrinking the gear and legislating more scoring chances.
They have failed to extinguish the quenchless quest to push the goaltending art. Even with the new changes goaltending continues to frustrate the shooters and will likely do so going forward.
One of the greatest innovations that goes hand and hand with this improvement, has been the invention of the “pro-fly” pads.
This pad design allows even mediocre goalies to get their pads vertical in the butterfly and allows them to have a flare width increase because of the knee lifts.
Pasco Valana Professional Goaltending Coach & Chief of Athlete Services for Olympic Ice Hockey 2010
The 2 most significant developments in goaltending in the past 10 years have been:
- Individual Customization for Goaltenders: high performance goaltenders right through to the professional ranks have changed their focus to work exclusively with strategic goaltending specialists to elevate their game and master consistency. Positional Adjustments, Defensive Zone Dissection, Timing Mechanisms and Mental Training Techniques have been the secret ingredients to top level goaltenders around the world. Not to be mistaken with generic one on one training, but specialists who are fluent in all goaltending languages who take the best elements of each style for the client and design a process that breeds consistency.
- Use of Video: The movement from VHS, to DVD, to On-line live Video Coaching has gained significant ground over the past decade. Having the ability to review video immediately after the game or practices with an athlete increases development, adjusts skills, improves strategies and makes immediate improvements in their overall game. Other benefits are increased preparation, reduction in “mental noise”, and increased consistency.
www.elitesportsmanagement.ca www.elitegoalies.com
Twitter: @goaliecoach
Risto Pakarinen Writer, The Hockey News
I think the most signifcant development is actually the same as with the skaters. The goalies are so much bigger than before, and so much more athletic that they can move faster, and do things goalies of the past couldn’t even dream of. And let’s not even get into a debate about the size of the equipment.
Twitter: @finnjewel
Joe Messina – Bandits Goaltending School Head Instructor
Over the past decade, goaltending has evolved due to the emphases on positioning and refining technique. Goaltenders have developed a more simplified style of game play. Whether it’s aggressive lateral movement, patience in the white ice or making controlled saves, goaltenders have become more athletic and have a better ability to read and react to plays. The overall goaltender as an athlete has become much quicker, stronger and educated, making them a greater threat to opposing players in the start of this new decade!
Twitter: @banditsgoalie
David Hutchison – inGoal Magazine Editor

The New Wave: Bruins Rookie Goalie Tuukka Rask is 6'3" 169 pounds. He leads the NHL in save % and GAA. In 1999-2000 there was only one Finnish goalie in the NHL Today, Rask can't even make the Finnish Olympic Team. Photo by Scott Slingsby.
After reading all the contributions that were submitted by our experts and being a bit of a numbers guy, I wanted to look at some stats. To say what was the most significant development in the past decade, I needed to see for myself what had changed.
Look back to the NHL goaltending statistics in 1999-2000 and you might say that nothing has changed. Martin Brodeur led the league with 43 wins and as I write this he sits atop the league again. The league leader in GAA was Rookie Brian Boucher at 1.91 – today it is Rookie Tuuka Rask at 1.92.
But of course much has changed. In 1999-2000 the league leaders in save % were Belfour/Theodore/Hasek at 0.919. Ten years ago that was a great number – today it’ll only put you 20th in the league, well behind leaders Rask and Miller at 0.934.
It’s a very rough look obviously but either the shooters are taking more low percentage shots or the goaltending is better today- and yes, the equipment shrunk somewhere along the way as well.
Lots of great goalies were there – the man credited with popularizing the butterfly (Roy), Theodore was strong technically and only a few years from his Vezina win but as many of our experts have suggested there were not nearly the number of polished technicians that you see today.
It’s not just about the technique though. Look at the names: Vanbiesbrouck, Rhodes, Healy, Vernon, Braithwaite. More smaller guys than we see now. Many Legace is taller than all of them! The numbers confirm it. In 1999-2000 the average NHL goalie was 6 feet tall and 192 pounds. Today they average 6′3″ and 196 pounds. 75% of them are taller than the average goalie in 1999-2000. Goaltenders are taller today and leaner (2.654 pounds per inch 10 years ago, 2.600 today – a 2% difference). Our experts said it – they are bigger and it would seem, more athletic.
For me the real shocker – and it has to be the most significant development – was the arrival of the European goalies. I would have assumed in such a small window of time the demographic makeup of the league would be the same, but not at all.
Ten years ago 71% of NL goalies were Canadian and 14% American. Only one Finn, one Swede, and one Russian! I have the names – maybe we’ll make it a trivia question and you can answer in the comments – who were they?
Today we sit at 49% Canadian, still 14% American, but 7 Finns have played this year, 5 Swedes, 4 Czechs and 3 Russians. Those aren’t just any European goalies either – they are amongst the elite in the league. Kipper, Nabby, Rask, King Henrik, Backstrom. They have arrived bigger than before (every Finnish goalie in the NHL today, for example, is taller than the NHL average goalie in 1999-2000), and they are technically sound thanks to highly structured and professional coaching. Yes, in Canada coaching has come a very long way but as Steve McKichan once mentioned to me, the Finns have a national curriculum for goaltending. Add to that the comment of their national junior coach that every young Finn wants to be a goalie and we can see what a powerful influence they, and their European bretheren have been on goaltending.
What do you think?
We’d love to hear your opinions – just hit the comment link and add to the conversation. Did we get it right? What did we miss? What will the landscape look like in 2020?





























