🎁 Know a goalie? Give them a year of pro-level training Gift a Subscription →
Photo illustration of Connor Hellebuyck in a New Jersey Devils jersey and white TRUE pads, set in his butterfly in front of the net

InGoal File Photo / Altered via AI

30 fewer goals? What Clear Sight Analytics says about Hellebuyck’s fit in New Jersey

When New Jersey Devils general manager Sunny Mehta was asked about the use of analytics in acquiring goalie Connor Hellebuyck from the Winnipeg Jets, he indicated the Devils use 14 different expected goals models as part of their evaluation process.

So, it seems goaltending isn’t the only thing in hockey with volatility 😉

Cheap jokes about analytics aside, InGoal Magazine has one model we trust when it comes to measuring shot quality and goaltending environments. So, what does Clear Sight Analytics, the company started and run by former NHL goalie Steve Valiquette, have to say about the Devils trading for Hellebuyck and how he’ll fit in New Jersey?

How about almost 30 fewer goals compared to Jacob Markstrom last season alone?

InGoal plugged Hellebuyck into Markstrom’s environment last season using the “Crease Swap” tool at Clear Sight Analytics and, according to their evaluation of 42 different types of scoring chances, the difference in 2025-26 would have been 29.18 fewer goals.

Doing the same for 2024-25, the difference is 15.73 goals in Hellebuyck’s favor.

So, what goes into that calculation and what does it mean?

If you’re new to Clear Sight Analytics or goalie analytics in general, we’d suggest getting started by re-visiting our primer of how the company measures shot quality.

In terms of how the Crease Swap tool works, it basically inserts Hellebuyck’s performance over the previous two seasons on every type of scoring chance into the number of those specific chances the new team — in this case, New Jersey — gave up in that particular season, and then lets you compare the results with each goalie.

In this case, it made sense to select Markstrom as the Devils No.1, and that meant a wider discrepancy for 2025-26 because it was a down season for Markstrom statistically, in part because he tried to play through injury more than once, while Hellebuyck’s statistics were based on a combination of his own “down” season in 2025-26 (more on that below) and his Hart- and Vezina-Trophy winning performance with Winnipeg in 2024-25.

Interestingly, despite the wide swing, Hellebuyck did not come out ahead in every category, and it will be important for the Devils to mind some of those differences defensively.

The caveat, of course, is that these numbers don’t necessarily translate directly from one team to another. Sure, Clear Sight Analytics measures the results on six different types of screen chances, for example, but that does not account for how the Devils might manage screen chances differently than Winnipeg and whether or not Hellebuyck, who is one of the greatest, if not the greatest, play-reading goalies in the game, has to adjust his own tactics.

Just because it isn’t perfect doesn’t mean it’s not worth a deeper dive, however. Clear Sight Analytics adds unparalleled levels of context when it comes to the defensive environment and goalie’s historical results on those specific chance types, so let’s take a closer look.

Still ahead in this article:

The specific quote from Mehta that quickly became 'Sunny hates goalies' headlines — and what he actually said after making the Hellebuyck trade to clarify it — is in the next paragraph.

INGOAL
Unlock the rest of this premium breakdown

Read this article free — just your email

I’m a…

Free, instant access. No credit card required.

or go unlimited

Join thousands of goalies, parents, and coaches who train smarter with InGoal.

15+ years of goaltending film & coaching

$49.99
CAD / YEAR · ≈ $35 USD
Less than a few skate sharpenings
See Membership Options

Think you're seeing this in error? Contact support

Save